If you can't view the message, please click here.

LLB Bulletin Header
LLB Bulletin #5/2024 8 May 2024

CASE HIGHLIGHTS

WONG WOEN MUN v. LYC MOTHER & CHILD CENTRE SDN BHD
INDUSTRIAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR
AUGUSTINE ANTHONY
AWARD NO. 344 OF 2024 [CASE NO: 4-4-2146-21]
5 MARCH 2024

AbstractA trained employee, who is employed for her experience, expertise and qualifications to perform a certain task falling under her job scope, cannot say that there was no proper standard operating procedures and training in place as she ought to have known her duties and responsibilities to perform such duty.

LABOUR LAW: Employment – Dismissal – Misconduct – Employer involved in business of providing care and nursing needs for mother and babies – Employee employed as Staff Nurse – Employee dismissed from employment due to work-related negligence – Mishandling of babies – Whether employee failed in discharge of duties and responsibilities as Staff Nurse – Whether acts of misconduct proven – Whether there was lack of standard operating procedures and training in handling babies – Whether there was condonation of misconduct – Whether there were acts of victimisation and favouritism by employee – Industrial Relations Act 1967, ss. 20(3) & 30(5)

TORT: Negligence – Work-related negligence – Misconduct – Employer involved in business of providing care and nursing needs for mother and babies – Employee employed as Staff Nurse – Employee dismissed from employment due to work-related negligence – Mishandling of babies – Whether employee failed in discharge of duties and responsibilities as Staff Nurse - Whether acts of misconduct proven


ROLAND EPPINGA lwn. CIMB INVESTMENT BANK BERHAD
MAHKAMAH PERUSAHAAN, KUALA LUMPUR
MOHD ZULBAHRIN ZAINUDDIN
AWARD NO. 394 TAHUN 2024 [NO. KES: 2-4-1374-21]
13 MAC 2024

AbstrakPenting dan menjadi satu keutamaan agar seorang pekerja diberikan penjelasan awal, melalui surat tunjuk sebab atau apa-apa bentuk siasatan lain, agar dia diberi pendedahan khusus dan menyeluruh tentang kekurangan dan kelemahan yang ada pada dirinya dan berpeluang untuk memberi penjelasan dan mempertahankan dirinya.

UNDANG-UNDANG BURUH: Pekerjaan – Penamatan kontrak perkhidmatan – Pihak menuntut dilantik untuk kontrak perkhidmatan tempoh tetap – Kontrak perkhidmatan dibaharui dan disambung setiap dua tahun dari 2015 hingga 2021 – Syarikat menamatkan kontrak perkhidmatan pihak menuntut sebelum tamat tempoh atas alasan kemerosotan prestasi – Sama ada kemerosotan prestasi berjaya dibuktikan – Sama ada tindakan-tindakan syarikat menyokong pengataan bahawa prestasi pihak menuntut merosot – Sama ada penamatan perkhidmatan adil – Akta Perhubungan Perusahaan 1967, s. 20(3)

KONTRAK: Kontrak perkhidmatan – Penamatan – Pihak menuntut dilantik untuk kontrak perkhidmatan tempoh tetap – Kontrak perkhidmatan dibaharui dan disambung setiap dua tahun dari 2015 hingga 2021 – Syarikat menamatkan kontrak perkhidmatan pihak menuntut sebelum tamat tempoh atas alasan kemerosotan prestasi – Sama ada kemerosotan prestasi berjaya dibuktikan – Sama ada tindakan-tindakan syarikat menyokong pengataan bahawa prestasi pihak menuntut merosot

LATEST CASES (ILR Issue 4 of 2024)

Award Parties Citation Links
  Chong Fui Thung v. Sena Diecasting Industries Sdn Bhd
[Civil Appeal No: W-01(A)-112-03-2023]
[2024] 2 ILR 1 cljlaw
labourlaw
  Monoluxury Sdn Bhd lwn. Willem Pomp
[Rayuan Sivil No: CB-12BNCVC-2-10-2022]
[2024] 2 ILR 14 cljlaw
labourlaw
  RHB Bank Bhd v. Tan Leong Huat
[Civil Appeal No: P-01(A)-202-03-2020]
[2024] 2 ILR 33 cljlaw
labourlaw
344/2024 Wong Woen Mun v. LYC Mother & Child Centre Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 4-4-2146-21]
[2024] 2 ILR 53 cljlaw
labourlaw
394/2024 Roland Eppinga lwn. CIMB Investment Bank Berhad
[No. Kes: 2-4-1374-21]
[2024] 2 ILR 71 cljlaw
labourlaw
410/2024 Hanizah Ahmad Jamaluddin v. Scomi KMC Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 3-4-2760-21]
[2024] 2 ILR 100 cljlaw
labourlaw
428/2024 Lee Huey Ming v. Smart Glove International Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 19-4-1087-23]
[2024] 2 ILR 121 cljlaw
labourlaw
443/2024 Mior Azizan Mior Aziz v. Lotuss Stores (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 10-4-673-22]
[2024] 2 ILR 135 cljlaw
labourlaw
474/2024 Mohd Razali Burhan v. Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd
[Case No: 17-4-766-21]
[2024] 2 ILR 169 cljlaw
labourlaw
495/2024 Kenny Bernard Saw v. Aumada Energy & Technologies (M) Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 11-4-613-22]
[2024] 2 ILR 189 cljlaw
labourlaw
499/2024 GS Yuasa Battery Malaysia Sdn Bhd v. Kesatuan Pekerja-pekerja Perusahaan Lektrik
[Case No: 18-2-290-23]
[2024] 2 ILR 217 cljlaw
labourlaw

SUBJECT INDEX

APPEAL/REVIEW UPDATES

  1. Chong Fui Thung v. Sena Diecasting Industries Sdn Bhd [2024] 2 ILR 1 (COA) overruling High Court decision of Sena Diecasting Industries Sdn Bhd v Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor [2023] CLJU 1274; [2023] 1 LNS 1274

  2. RHB Bank Bhd v. Tan Leong Huat [2024] 2 ILR 33 (COA) overruling High Court decision of RHB Bank Bhd v. Tan Leong Huat [Judicial Review Application No: PA-25-26-06-2019].




Annual   Publish   LLB Blog
         
Hourly   Submit   Training

CLJ WEBSITES

(Available with separate subscription plan)

FOLLOW US

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Feedback
Copyright © 2024 MYLAWBOX Sdn Bhd To unsubscribe click here